Life as I Know It; Family; Lifestyle; and Healthy Living!

This has been the topic of discussion on many a occasion and lately I've seen it played out in scenarios on ABC's Primetime!  Today I read an article on slate.com where a woman was asking "Dear Prudence" for advice because she somehow messed up her friend's relationship with the friend's husband because she made it slip that he has a secret he's keeping from her!  This was done in the heat of the moment when she was 'bending' her friend's ear about her relationship with her selfish boyfriend who doesn't want to get married because their relationship would change and he's happy the way they are now!

 

On Primetime, they set up scenarios with the permission of a couple, wherein the man would be at a restaurant with another woman, being too familiar with each other, and the best friend would be there, 'catching' him and not knowing what to do! 

 

The scenario played out that the friend, text the boyfriend to say she was there and could see everything he was doing.  The boyfriend would look guilty and quickly leave with the 'woman' and then the best friend would be in a quandary as to whether or not she should say anything to her friend about it!

 

It's been interesting to see what each person in the situation does.  While the women who have been in that situation end up telling their friend, which I think is a good thing, they usually are really troubled on what they should do and how they should go about telling their friend.

 

I would prefer to know that my friend is looking out for my interest and would want to know what's going on!  Otherwise, she wouldn't be a good friend.  Because if she can't tell me something like that, then there would be something wrong with our relationship!  I can appreciate however, the angst and foreboding my best friend would feel about it, the way those women did!

 

You know what would be interesting though, if they put a man in that role, I would love to see what a guy's reaction would be and if he would tell his buddy about it!


Comments
on Mar 10, 2008
No, I would not tell. This happened to me once. I told my best friend his wife was cheating on him and when the dust settled, they worked things out and I was the bad guy. Later on, as cheaters usually do, she cheated on him again and they divorced -but I remained the bad guy and disliked by BOTH of them. So the only thing telling him accomplished was that I lost a friendship, really two, that I enjoyed.

Of course on the other hand, who wants to be friends with someone that will bail on you when you tell them the truth? Anyway, I'll never chance that again.
on Mar 10, 2008
I'd tell. But only if I was absolutely sure.
on Mar 10, 2008

I'd probably tell my friend, but only a really good friend that trusts me enough to know I wouldn't fuck with him/her when it came to that. 

I just pray that it never happens on my watch...it looks awkward as all hell.

~Zoo

on Mar 10, 2008

Of course on the other hand, who wants to be friends with someone that will bail on you when you tell them the truth? Anyway, I'll never chance that again.

 

I understand.  I can't imagine how painful that must have been for you!

 

This happened to me once. I told my best friend his wife was cheating on him and when the dust settled, they worked things out and I was the bad guy. Later on, as cheaters usually do, she cheated on him again and they divorced -but I remained the bad guy and disliked by BOTH of them. So the only thing telling him accomplished was that I lost a friendship, really two, that I enjoyed.

That's sad Roy!  Really sad and shows how much he valued you as a friend.  Too bad!

 

 

I'd tell. But only if I was absolutely sure.

When it's staring you in the face the way it was those in the scene!  And yes, being absolutely sure would be the key thing here!  Going on suspicions would be an idiotic thing to do!

 

1) She may already know and be choosing to ignore it. 2) She may already know and simply hasn't shared it with you. 3) Interfering with a marital relationship is VERBOTEN. 4) No matter what the outcome, you run the big risk of being made the 'bad guy.'

Absolutely!  These are valid reasons.  But it would make me feel even worse knowing what I do and not being able to anything about it.  I wouldn't be able to stay friends.

 

Never, ever step between a husband and wife. It may cost you your friendship,

I don't usually but in a case like this, if my friend can't stand hearing the truth, then what's the use of being friends? 

I look at it like this, if my friend and I tell each other everthing, I mean every gory details and we have been friends for years, I would want her to tell me and I would do the same in return.

I think people who react in the opposite way and blame the friend is immature.  it  is goona hurt for sure, but what would be the sense if my friend know and didn't say anything?  That's awful!  It would make me wonder what else did they know and didn't tell me about other things; how truthful they have been in the friend relationship...stuff like that!

 

I understand the problems that doing it would cause, and I understand how painful it is but I would want to know.

 

...it looks awkward as all hell.

 

It is!  It would be difficult caught in a situation like that!

 

 

on Mar 10, 2008
What I'd do is let the cheater know I know, and encourage them to pay me money to keep me quiet.


Fixed.
on Mar 10, 2008
NO! Take Roy's advice. If they patch things up, you may lose a friend. And she will find out eventually anyway.
on Mar 10, 2008

I'd talk to the cheater.  Tell him I know and I am not going to keep secrets or lie for him.  Hopefully it would compel him to tell his wife...

I did the same thing Roy did TWICE!  I told both times, both times they reconciled, and both times they hated me. 

But I'd still tell the cheater, I know.  Just not my gal pal.

on Mar 10, 2008
If blaming me can save their marriage, by golly let them blame me all they want.
on Mar 10, 2008
I would want to know therefore I would tell. It would have to be a close friend though. If it was just someone I knew but wasn't close with, I would count it as none of my business.
on Mar 10, 2008

If they patch things up, you may lose a friend

If she were a close friend then it wouldn't have been worth it being friends in the first place.  I would miss her, but I wouldn't be sorry that I said something.

I did the same thing Roy did TWICE! I told both times, both times they reconciled, and both times they hated me.

That's awful!  Why do they react that way I wonder? 

 

I'd talk to the cheater. Tell him I know and I am not going to keep secrets or lie for him. Hopefully it would compel him to tell his wife...

My loyalty would be to her, not him.  I guess since I've not been in that situation, it might be different for me.  But my instincts would be just the same.

 

It would have to be a close friend though. If it was just someone I knew but wasn't close with, I would count it as none of my business.

Yes.  A very close friend is my thinking.  I have three friends who I'm really really close to. I would want to know.

 

A relative of mine found out his wife was cheating on him.  Others knew but didn't say. He found out himself.  If he hadn't found out the way he did, he would have never known.  He was hurt because the people he trusted, didn't say anything.  That's hard to take.

 

I guess people are different.

on Mar 13, 2008

There is no gray with this issue is there?  People either will tell or won't.  I think I'd probably fall into the won't tell category mostly for the reason that I would never come between a couple like this.  However, I think I would let the cheater know I know and let them decide what to do.  Hopefully, they will make the right decision themselves.

on Mar 13, 2008
I think I'd probably fall into the won't tell category mostly for the reason that I would never come between a couple like this.


Which couple?

The couple is already been come between at this point...
on Mar 13, 2008

 

However, I think I would let the cheater know I know and let them decide what to do. Hopefully, they will make the right decision themselves.

Hopefully, they would make the right decision.  The only reason I would tell my girlfriend is because she and I would be the one in a better/sister-like relationship.  Unless it was a couple with whom I had the same equal closeness to, then I would feel obligated to say something to the person who is doing the cheating and let him/her figure it out from there.

 

Which couple? The couple is already been come between at this point...

I was about to respond to your question,  then I remember about your scarcastic humor!LOL!